Who will be interested in the information on this page?
Anyone interested in information about:
- making a Will
- the role of the executor
- what capacity is needed to make a valid Will
- what happens if there is no Will
- challenging a Will
- what constitutes a valid Will
- what invalidates a Will
- myths about Wills
What is a Will:
A Will is a written, signed and witnessed document which expresses your wishes about how your assets will be distributed after your death.
Your executor has a legal obligation to promptly carry out the wishes in the Will.
What is an executor?
Your executor is the person or company you appoint to represent your estate. The executor’s role is (amongst other things) to safeguard your assets, make funeral arrangements, pay any debts, finalise any taxation matters, and distribute assets according you your wishes.
The most common executors by far are spouses and children (or in other cases, the principal beneficiaries in your Will). But any person can be appointed – the person should be someone who you can trust to take on this role. Executors are subject to very strict rules propriety. If a suitable individual cannot be found a professional trustee company may be appointed, but these companies will charge the estate fees. Executors who are family members and other individuals won’t usually be entitled to any fees/commission.
Sometimes solicitors are appointed as executors, but this firm does not recommend this.
Executors do not need to see and/or read the Will prior to the death of the Will maker.
Capacity to make a Will:
For a Will to be valid a three pronged test must be satisfied.
The Will maker must know and understand:
- What a Will is and its effect.
- What their estate is comprised of (but not in minute detail).
- Who the people are who might (not necessary will) share in their estate – those persons who should be taken into consideration.
This test will not usually be necessary to consider for a younger healthy Willmaker (we are obviously talking about the date when the Will was made), but often has critical importance for elderly people where capacity is often relevant, especially where some dementia or diminished capacity is known to be present.
It is possible for a person with dementia, or other incapacity, to make a valid Will, but an experienced solicitor should be involved to avoid challenges to validity after death. It should also be noted that even if a medical practitioner has given an opinion that a person does not have capacity to make a Will, this is not determinative (for example, the doctor may have been asked the wrong questions or not been provided with the correct legal test for capacity).
The question of the capacity of an elderly person to make a valid Will is a special interest of this firm.
Formal requirements of Wills:
The formal requirements for a valid Will in Victoria are set out in the Wills Act.
- that the Will must be in writing
- that the Will maker must be at least 18 years of age (unless married)
- that two witness must be present when the Will is signed and see it being signed, and each sign their name
There are also some “informal” requirements – for example, the same pen should be used by the Willmaker and the two witness – this is not in the Wills Act but (if Probate is applied for). The Registrar of Probates will require evidence that the formal requirements about execution were carried out, if it is apparent that a different pen was used in signing and witnessing the Will.
Types of Wills:
It goes without saying that some Wills are simple and some are long and complex.
But there are some broad categories of Wills.
Husband and wife Wills – sometimes called mirror image Wills, and sometimes (wrongly from the legal point of view) “mutual Wills”. These are basically the same Will with identical terms – usually making each other executor and leaving everything to each other, and then to children.
Mutual Wills – these are quite complex in concept and involve an agreement by both Will makers (usually husband and wife or partners) that the survivor will not to alter his or her Will. This type of Will is often used in blended families where it is desired that step children will be properly benefitted where the step-child’s own parent dies first.
Wills with testamentary trusts – while most Wills have some form of simple and usually short term trust created in them, it is possible to set up a more complex trust arrangement which will commence only upon the death of the Willmaker and which will be designed to have long term effect. These are called testamentary trusts, and the full terms of the trust will be included as part of the Will. These may be set up as, for example, family discretionary trusts. Family discretionary trusts are often created to protect family wealth and can protect children from losing assets if they have financial or matrimonial difficulties or if a partner has gambling or business problems.
See our separate page on this topic which contains more detail.
With some important exceptions, the only people in Victoria who can challenge a Will are spouses/partners, children and step-children. This extends to challenges to estates where there is no Will and the laws of intestacy don’t adequately benefit the challenger.
The challenging person must establish that the deceased had a moral duty to provide for him or her and did not adequately do so, or did not do so at all.
A gift in a Will to a beneficiary does not prevent that beneficiary challenging – as it is the adequacy of the gift that the law is concerned about.
Events that invalidate Wills:
- Divorce will invalidate an existing Will (with some exceptions).
- Marriage will invalidate an existing Will (again, with some exceptions).
- The Willmaker not having the (cognitive) capacity to make a Will.
- Improper execution (signing and witnessing)
What if there is no Will:
Many people die without leaving a Will.
This is called an “intestacy”.
When this happens a person (usually the person who will be the major beneficiary) can apply for “Letters of Administration”. This has the same effect as obtaining Probate – the appointed person becomes the legal representative of the deceased estate and can deal with the administration of the estate.
The appointed person will have a legal duty to distribute net assets according to the provisions of the formula set out in the relevant legislation (the Administration and Probate Act). The formula provides that progressively more distant relatives will benefit in a particular way and in particular proportions, depending on which relatives exist.
The distribution of the estate in such a fashion may not be what the deceased wanted, and this is the primary reason why everyone should make a Will.
Myths about Wills:
Solicitors often encounter unexpected misunderstandings about Wills. Here are some (all of the below are true):
Changing addresses (of the Willmaker, executor/s or beneficiary/s) does not invalidate a Will.
The State does not take the assets of a deceased if there is no valid Will (the assets will go to close relatives according to a formula in legislation).
Husband and wife, for example, can’t have their Wills drawn in the same document – although this is probably strictly possible, if the formalities in the Wills Act are carried out, it is not something that should be done.
A Will won’t fail if there is no executor appointed or if the executor dies before the Willmaker.
A Will won’t fail if a particular gift in the Will fails.
A person can have two (or more) Wills – this is sometimes done if the person has assets in two jurisdictions – for example, in Australia and the United Kingdom (but don’t try this at home!)
In Victoria a beneficiary in a Will can be a witness to that Will.
In Victoria an executor appointed in a Will can be a witness to that Will.
There is no such thing as the “reading of the Will” – there is no requirement for this – it is something out of Hollywood movies.
A “peppercorn” gift in a Will, that is, a gift of a negligible amount, will not disqualify the person receiving it from making a challenge to the Will.